Difference Between Modern and Carriage House Style Garage Doors

Modern Garage Doors in Chicago_

When it comes to choosing a garage door for your home, there are a variety of different styles to choose from. Modern and carriage house-style garage doors are two of the most popular options for homeowners. While both options can provide an attractive addition to your home, they have distinct characteristics that set them apart.

This blog will discuss the difference between modern and carriage house-style garage doors to help you choose which door is right for your garage and overall property. Find out the answer and contact AR-BE Garage Doors to equip your home with the best, most affordable, and most durable garage door in the Chicagoland area. Keep reading to get all of the answers!

Modern Garage Doors


Modern garage doors tend to have an elegant, minimalist layout distinguished by clean lines and a contemporary appearance. These doors are often made of steel or aluminum, enhancing their beauty and durability. They may also feature large windows or glass panels, letting in natural light and creating an open, airy feel in the garage. This option is amazing for those who use their garage as an extra space for guests or for those who do a lot of work within their garage. In addition, the materials used in a modern garage door can come in various textures and colors, making it more customizable and versatile.

Benefits of Modern Garage Doors

When it comes to modern garage doors, there are various benefits that homeowners can take advantage of. Some of the primary benefits include:

They are Often More Energy Efficient

As a way to help consumers save money on their monthly electricity bills, manufacturers are creating more energy-efficient garage doors! In addition, they often feature better insulation which assists in keeping the garage door at a more consistent temperature throughout the year. This is essential for garages attached to your home, especially during winter.

Technological Advancements

Manufacturers are delivering as consumers search for new and unique designs and design features for garage doors. Some modern garage doors on the market come with various new and exciting smart features such as automatic opening and closing, fingerprint access, and even voice activation. These features not only provide ease, but they deliver enhanced security as well.
One of the best examples of “smart” advancements is access from your phone or smart device. For example, an automatic opener compatible with your modern garage door can be activated easily by pressing a button through a smartphone app. This allows you to open and close the garage door without leaving your home or stepping out of your car. Therefore, if you are in a hurry or want to completely avoid those harsh and cold Illinois winter days, it can now be done with modern garage doors and openers.

Improved Durability

Another one of the greatest benefits of modern garage doors is their durability. Many modern doors out on the market are made from materials resistant to decay and rust. This means they can last for years with minimal maintenance or failure. Thanks to their durability make, they a great choice for those who need a long-lasting and low-maintenance solution for their garage.

Carriage House Style Garage Doors

On the other side of things, some homeowners want to transport the style and appearance of their home to the past. For example, carriage house-style garage doors are designed to mimic the look of traditional carriage house doors from the 19th century. These doors are typically more decorative and ornate than modern garage doors, with features such as decorative hardware and windows that resemble those found in carriage houses. They are usually made from wood and can be painted or stained to match the look of a traditional carriage house.

Carriage house-style garage doors are more suitable for homes that have a traditional or historic architectural style. These garage doors are great options for homeowners who want to add a touch of historic charm to their homes. In addition, the warm and inviting appearance of a carriage house-style door can add to your home’s curb appeal, making it more inviting and welcoming to visitors.

Benefits of Carriage House Style Garage Doors

If you want to keep the style of your home a little bit more “old school,” then carriage house style house garage doors may be the best option. There are various benefits to these types of garage doors, and they include:

Highly Customizable

One of the primary benefits of carriage house-style garage doors is that you can completely customize them to match the style and look of your home. They can be stained or painted to match the color of your home. In addition, they can be manufactured in various styles, including:

  • Swing-out
  • Bi-folding
  • Sliding

This allows you to create a truly unique door that reflects your personal style. Therefore, if you want to stand out from other residences in your neighborhood, this garage door is one of the main options you have to choose from.

Made From Natural Materials

Another additional benefit of carriage house-style garage doors is that they are often made from natural materials, such as wood, which means they are more environmentally friendly than modern garage doors, which are generally made from metal or plastic. As a result, this can be a great choice for homeowners looking for a more sustainable option for their garages.

The Downside of Carriage House-Style Garage Doors

While there are many advantages to this style of garage door, there are various downsides to them. Therefore, ensure to check with your garage door provider about all of the potential downsides before purchasing. Some of them include the following:

  1. They require more maintenance because they are generally made from natural materials such as wood. Therefore, they are prone to warping, rotting, and other forms of damage if it is not properly maintained. In addition, they also require constant painting and staining to maintain their appearance and protect the property from the elements.
  2. Not very energy efficient: When compared to modern garage doors, carriage house-style garage doors are not as energy efficient. They often lack sufficient insulation, leading to increased cooling and heating costs.
  3. More expensive: These garage doors may be more expensive since they are typically custom-made, and the craftsmanship and materials required to build them are more expensive.

But while carriage house-style garage doors can add a touch of historic charm to your home, they require more attention and can potentially make you spend more money in the future. However, it all depends on your functionality and aesthetic preferences regarding your garage.

Choose The Modern Garage Doors That Is Right For You With AR-BE

Still not sure what garage door is right for you? No worries, AR-BE is here to help. Their array of garage door options, alongside their team of garage door specialists, will help you weigh each door’s pros and cons and provide you with recommendations that fit your wants, needs, and budgets. So contact an expert today and get all the answers you are searching for.

Scroll to Top